“WE CAN’T FIX CORRUPTION – IT’S PART OF OUR CULTURE”


The 7th Pan Africa Conference for Modernization of the Public Sector in Morocco was organized on the theme of breaking the culture of corruption in government.  I was fortunate enough to be invited to speak to the delegates at the initial plenary sessions.  (Click here for the details – Fundamental Issues in Modernizing the Public Sector.) After the presentation I had the chance to speak with several of the Ambassadors and official government spokespersons from several of the countries.

Each conversation included a pronouncement by the person that “we can never fix corruption because it is part of our culture.”

This verbal declaration of despair wasn’t limited to government officials. I heard it from media representatives, anticorruption NGOs, and shopkeepers.

They say it, but it is not true.

I often point out to such people that they do not live with the same “culture” as their parents. And they invariably acknowledge that their own children will likely live by different cultural standards.

I also point out that all of the international hotel chains hire staff from all over the world and are able to create a corporate culture of quality and high performance.

In truth, we are not prisoners to our “culture.” Despite how it sometimes feels.

The starting point is understanding that “culture” is the habits and customs distributed amongst a population. It is distributed by formal and informal education. It changes, evolves and grows or dies by formal and informal education.

Thus, the real question is: What must we do to bring about a positive long-term change in government and business culture?

I have shared my white paper on the fundamental institutional tools needed to control corruption. I have also shared my thoughts on this subject with several online groups (LinkedIn, Facebook, the “How to Fight Corruption”, Organizational Corruption and Global Transitions & Development).

I find nearly unanimous agreement with the IDEAS discussed. The difficulties seem to arrive BEFORE implementation.

The challenge seems to be the willingness to confront the challenge of re-educating an entire corporation, government institution or society.

Willingness to Confront the Challenge

I personally saw an example where a senior government official wanted to have specific technical training developed for his staff that would qualify them for international professional certification. They all performed critical government oversight roles.

As part of the training development my team wanted to accurately assess the skills of the government staff. The Senior Official refused to allow a math skills assessment. After avoiding the question for several weeks, he relented and explained that he knew that his people would be unable to perform on the skills assessment at even the primary school level.

Question: “So how do you expect me to develop training that will qualify them for international certification if we cannot discuss the training needed to prepare them for certification?”

Answer: “I don’t know. But we can’t address them at their actual skill level. They will be insulted. Therefore, you cannot do an actual skills assessment.”

Most of the staff actually wanted to identify and address known and suspected shortcomings. But were not allowed to participate in the skills assessment because their boss was worried about the appearance.

There are many ways to address this problem. However, all of the ways require a willingness to face the problem.

One cannot implement any form of culture change, whether it is a new standard operating procedure or a culture of corruption, unless one is willing to face the actual situation in front of them.

If we can’t face the problem – we can never fix it.

Brian Pinkowski

Other Useful Links:

A brief description of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act

Using Public Administration Skills to Fight Corruption. An interview with The Economist

U.S. Department of State – Speakers Bureau Info: Brian Pinkowski

Advertisements

13 thoughts on ““WE CAN’T FIX CORRUPTION – IT’S PART OF OUR CULTURE”

  1. There is no culture of corruption. It is a question of having serious leadership that incalcates a culture of positive values that allow citizens to have patriotic thinking and act “patriotic”. Corruption can be found in any society if leadership allows it to take root. I am a strong believer in leadership to be everything in the world we live in. Good leadership breeds good leaders and good people free of corrupt mind.

    1. Kalisa, Leadership seems to be a critical factor. Its seems that we often leave the quality of leadership to chance in most societies. Perhaps we can map out options for developing integrity in leaders rather than relying on them to simply tell us about their integrity.

      I am not aware of any sort of integrity index for leaders, but it might be interesting to develop such an index.

  2. I am in international development work and had seen action across many countries and sadly, I have come across corruption in almost every country I worked and in almoxt every INGO I have worked with.

    Sadly, when the alarm is raised people at the top of the organizations tend to shy away from it and sweep the issue under the carpet. Even the UN field operations is not immune from corruption.

    I question the moral ascendancy we have to preach anti-corruption measures and mitigation when the very agencies supposedly there to safeguard against corruption closes its eyes to corruption within its ranks.

    I can share many experiences I have in this field (despite the maturity of the systems of checks and balances). I can assure you that corruption is alive and kicking in humanitarian and development programmes across the world.

  3. Hi there,
    with all due respect to others opinions.
    We might say corruption is a part of our culture it might have become, because we have accepted it. But we all cry when it hurts us personally that is the fact.
    Why not to up root it for sure it won’t be easy, but here is hope.
    Medically if a part of the body has got gangrene doctors advice in order for whole body to survive, that particular part of the body has to be amputate and we do make the right choice that time, don’t we?
    Biblically Mark 9: 42-48″ if a part of your body causes you to sin cut it off it is better for you to enter life maimed then with two hands to go into hell, so corruption to me is like sickness which eventually destroys the whole body and the whole nation, as someone says corruption is grit in the machine it is not a grease in the machine, for sure grit will destroy the machine.
    Lets join hand in uprooting the corruption, my personal Prayer may the youth the power of the world get sick of corruption and rise against it untidily.
    Have great day!
    Rajan Dass.

  4. Pingback: Pemberantasan-korupsi

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s